Summary:
Certified reference methods and certified reference materials for realisation of traceability in measuring serum
glucose, cholesterol, creatinine, total protein and albumin are available. If the values of working calibrators are
traceable to these reference methods and materials then comparable results of routine measurements should be
obtained – different calibrators are harmonised. Harmonisation of calibrators is considered a strong tool for
comparability improvement at least to the level of quality requirements defined as medical needs. We used four
calibrators from three manufacturers for calibration of measurement systems Roche Modular-Abbott (two
concentration levels), Roche, Olympus and studied the level of their harmonisation. Large systematic differences,
larger than medical requirements were found in cholesterol, creatinine, total protein and albumin measure -
ments. The highest systematic differences were found for total protein and albumin measurements but significant
differences were even detected in cholesterol estimations, where traceability can be easily realised by a well
established international reference system. Differences between calibrators Roche and Olympus were lower than
between calibrators Abbott and the others. In many cases even maximal differences were obtained between two
Abbott calibrators despite of their identical origin. The conclusion from results of this study is that traceability
realisation is either not well done or is not effective. Harmonisation between tested calibrators is often very low
and these calibrators cannot be used out the framework of individual homogenous routine measurement systems.
On the other hand results of external quality assessment show much better interlaboratory comparability than
could be expected from observed low calibrators harmonisation. It means that results reached by laboratories
in external quality assessment do not reflect the real level of traceability.
Key words:
traceability, working calibrators, systematic differences, harmonisation, medical needs.
|