Summary:
Introduction: Prospective study comparing four methods of postoperative analgesia with regard to the following criteria: pain relief during bed-rest
and rehabilitation; the effect on ventilation and the occurrence of side effects.
Study population and types of intervention: Ninety-two patients scheduled for cardiac surgery via sternotomy were enrolled in the study during the
period from autumn 1998 to spring 1999. The patients were randomized into four groups. Balanced general anaesthesia was administered. Within
first 48 hours after the completion of surgery, patients were periodically assessed in 612 hours intervals and also during rehabilitation. We assessed
pain according to VAS, hemodynamic parameters, spirometric values, arterial blood gases, depth of sedation and side effects of pain control.
Following types of analgesia were compared:
a) Mixture of ketamine 400 mg and sufentanil 100 mcg in 50 ml syringe, administered in a continuous infusion, rate of infusion 0.53.5 ml/hr
(group A)
b) Mixture of bupivacaine 0.5% 12.5 ml and sufentanil 50 mcg in 50 ml syringe, administered epidurally, rate of infusion 38 ml/hr (group B)
c) Morphine administered by nurse in 2 mg boluses prn (group C)
d) Morphine administered using PCA system: 10 mg/20 ml, bolus dose 1 ml, lock-out interval 5 min (group D).
Results: We found statistically significant less pain during bed rest and rehabilitation in patients treated with epidurally administered analgesic
mixture. During the postoperative period, in all groups spirometric functions decreased; the least decrease was in the group treated epidurally. Those
patients had also higher oxygenation index; however, that value did not reach statistical significance. Sedation was equal in all groups. The most
common adverse effect of pain control was nausea; in two cases in group A we observed respiratory depression.
Discussion: We fail to reach ideal postoperative analgesia of 3 and less according to VAS. We confirmed literary data on beneficial effect of epidural
analgesia on ventilation and rehabilitation. With respect to this, we prefer that type of analgesia. PCA suited to the patients but not all of them were
able to operate the device by themselves. There were also technical difficulties with that particular type of syringe pump. Intermittent bolus
administration of morphine administered by nurse as requested leads to more frequent pain outbreak episodes, possibly caused by significant fluctuation
of plasma level of the given drug.
Key words:
epidural analgesia - patient controlled analgesia ketamine - morphine
|