TOF-Watch® SX vs. Datex-Ohmeda M-NMT: A comparison of the TOF-ratio measured with accelerometry
or electromyography. A clinical, prospective, controlled study.
Adamus M.1, Adamus P.2, Belohlávek R.3, Vujcíková M.1, Janásková E.1
1Klinika anesteziologie a resuscitace, Fakultní nemocnice a Lékarská fakulta Univerzity Palackého, Olomouc 2Rapid System, s. r. o., Olomouc 3Katedra informatiky, Prírodovedecká fakulta Univerzity Palackého, Olomouc |
|
Summary:
Objective: To compare the TOF-ratio measured with acceleromyography (ACC) and electromyography
(EMG) during cis-atracurium or rocuronium-induced neuromuscular blockade. To determine the effectiveness
of accelerometry for detection of a residual block.
Design: Clinical, prospective, comparative, controlled study.
Setting: Department of Anaesthesiology and Intensive Care, University Hospital.
Materials and Methods: Following local ethics committee approval and obtaining informed consent, 47
patients scheduled for elective surgery under total intravenous anaesthesia with tracheal intubation and
muscle relaxation were studied. In each consecutive patient, accelerometry (TOF-Watch® SX, Organon) and
electromyography (Datex-Ohmeda) were used simultaneously to determine theTOF-ratio. Paired TOF-ratios
were compared and bias, limits of agreement, sensitivity, specificity and validity for the accelerometric
detection of the residual block were calculated.
Results: 1,505 paired measurements of TOF were obtained (TOFEMG and TOFACC). The average difference
in the TOF-ratios showed a bias of –1.4% (SD 10.9). The limits of agreement (range in which 95% of the differences
between paired measurements are expected to lie) were -23.3 to +20.5%. The sensitivity, specificity
and validity of accelerometry to detect recovery from the neuromuscular block (TOFEMG ³ 90%) were
47, 97 and 92% respectively. Both measurement techniques provided reliable information about the degree
of neuromuscular block. Under the described study conditions accelerometry was able to detect residual
neuromuscular blockade with acceptable precision.
Conclusion: Accelerometry (TOF-Watch® SX) is a reliable clinical tool for the detection of a residual block
but its results cannot be used interchangeably with electromyography (Datex-Ohmeda).
Key words:
neuromuscular blockade – electromyography – accelerometry – TOF-ratio
|