CzMA JEP Home page CZECH MEDICAL ASSOCIATION J. Ev. PURKYNĚ
Journals - Article
CzMA JEP Home page News About Assocation Publishing Division Medical Journals Searching Supplements Catalogue
 
  Česky / Czech version Čes. Radiol., 56, 2002, No. 3, p. 163-170
 
Interobserver Variation in Iliac Artery Stenosis Quantification and Comparison of the Stenosis with Transstenotic Pressure Gradients 
Peregrin J. H.1, Roček M.1, Krajíčková D.1, Laštovičková J.1, Kováč J.1,Novotný J.1, Kožnar B.1, Borůvka V 2, Kčcher M.3, Krajina A 4 

Základna radiodiagnostiky a intervenční radiologie, IKEM, Praha,l přednosta doc. MUDr. Jan Peregrin, CSc.Radiodiagnostické oddělení Nemocnice Na Homolce, Praha,2 přednostka MUDr. Ladislava Janoušková, CSc. Radiologická klinika FN, Olomouc,přednosta prof. MUDr. Josef Nekula, CSc.4 Radiologická klinika FN, Hradec Králove, přednosta doc. MUDr. Pavel
 


Summary:

       Objective: Comparison of interobserver variation in a) angiographic quantification of iliac artery stenosis and b) indications for stem implantation. Comparison of stenosis quantification with measured transstenotic systolic pressure gradient. Materiál and methods: 26 „diagnostic" angiographies, 10 post PTA angiographies and 19 angiographies after stem implantation were independently reviewed by 4 observers: 3 were from outside hospitals, 1 of our Institute. Subjective quantification of stenosis severity was compared between the observers and also to the measured pressure gradient. Recommendation for stem implantation made by individual readers were tabulated. Results: Interobserver agreement for stenosis severity was poor, especially for the group of diagnostic angiographies where ranked between 37 - 100 %. When compared to transstenotic pressure gradients the agreement was also poor and in some observers is Glose to 50 % only. Similarly the indication for stem implantation is not uniform as well and differed notably from observer to observer. Conclusion: Significant variability in estimation of iliac artery stenosis severity was found between four independent readers. There is also significant variability in recommendation for stem implantation. Thus, there is little uniformity in angiographic evaluation and treatment plans among interventional radiologists in our country.

        Key words: iliac PTA - angiography - interobserver evaluation variability
       

Order this issue

  BACK TO CONTENTS  
 
 
| HOME PAGE | CODE PAGE | CZECH VERSION |
©  1998 - 2008 CZECH MEDICAL ASSOCIATION J. E. PURKYNĚ
Created by: NT Servis, s.r.o., hosted by P.E.S. consulting, s.r.o.
WEBMASTER